When the Vermont General Assembly returns to Montpelier on January 6th, the legislators will face significant challenges.  In the second session of our 79th Biennium, the committees will continue to work on complicated, long-term issues. They will continue to take on education reform, seeking the best way to provide a quality education for all of Vermont’s K-12 students at a cost that communities will support. Other committees will pick up on their own ongoing efforts to increase the availability of affordable homes in Vermont. The Health Care Committee will build on their work to tackle rising medical care and health insurance costs.  The Appropriations Committee will make tough spending decisions in a tight budget year. And all of this work, along with that of the other committees, will need to be accomplished in the face of federal uncertainty and bellicosity.

Despite these challenges, I am eager to get back to the State House to continue in my role as Chair of the House Judiciary Committee. Although I will continue to follow and provide input on other issues facing the House, my focus will be on the work of the Judiciary Committee.

There, we will continue to focus on improving public safety and access to justice. The committee will conduct oversight hearings to understand whether our increased funding of courts, prosecutors, defense counsel, and victim advocates has led to swifter and more certain consequences. We will also examine other initiatives to expedite processing of both criminal and civil cases.

We will analyze any recommendations from the so-called “accountability court,” a pilot project in Chittenden County that runs into February.  A special prosecutor, assigned judge, and dedicated service providers are focusing there on expeditiously resolving the cases of repeat offenders in the county. The early results of the pilot are promising, but not necessarily surprising – for the past three years, my committee has been advocating for just such an influx of resources as is being provided, albeit temporarily, for the pilot project.

Last year, one of the Judiciary Committee’s priorities was to take a deep dive into our juvenile justice system. We passed Act 4, which implemented some changes, and that work will continue in the coming session with a focus on our Youthful Offender (YO) law.  

The current YO law provides an alternative to adult criminal court for youth ages 14 to 22, allowing their cases to be handled confidentially in Family Court if certain criteria are met. An individual with YO status may be placed on juvenile probation with both the Department of Children and Families and the Department of Corrections having jurisdiction over the individual. The focus of juvenile probation, and generally of YO status, is rehabilitation with services like education, treatment, and job training. The goal of YO status is to prevent long-term collateral consequences for the youth and allow them to avoid having a criminal record. If the youth violates their probation, however, the individual may be transferred back to the criminal court for sentencing, which helps ensure accountability.

In the coming session, the Judiciary Committee will study different ideas to improve the YO law. We will consider strengthening provisions related to accountability of YO participants and expanding victims’ rights in the law.

The intersection of mental health and substance use disorder with the criminal justice system will also be a hot issue in the coming session, although I anticipate that the Senate Judiciary and Health and Human Services Committees will address this initially.  They may consider the creation of a forensic facility to hold highly violent offenders with severe mental illness and may work towards implementing a competency restoration system.

As I discussed in my most recent column, the Judiciary Committee will also continue its focus on concerns brought on by what is happening at the federal level and in other states. We will seek ways to ameliorate impacts on vulnerable Vermonters, including undocumented and immigrant members of our communities. In addition to these matters, the Judiciary Committee will likely consider bills related to voyeurism, animal cruelty, voter intimidation, and other matters. It promises to be a busy session for the committee.